Clandestine employment of Indians in Italy | DW Documentary (Migrant documentary)

6 470
368
 
KOMMENTARE
NiX aKi
NiX aKi - Vor 4 Tage
You're still lucky compared to the situations in the rest of the world. However, I still wish they would treat you equally in thr very near future.
Spear Tip
Spear Tip - Vor 8 Tage
Earning€3per hour is not a bad work, in Manipur India non skill laborer earns only₹300 per day, if I'm wrong correct me
Marıø
Marıø - Vor 12 Tage
What a shame
prafulla more
prafulla more - Vor 13 Tage
It's flow of human capital from excess to short place just like money.
said awdars
said awdars - Vor 14 Tage
Modern slavery..
Zell Ilumblade
Zell Ilumblade - Vor 15 Tage
The next time you thank god for your meals, thank him for the shit conditions he puts these people through to get you your meals on the cheap.
baljeet singh khosa
baljeet singh khosa - Vor 17 Tage
Well done dw
Joe Airbender
Joe Airbender - Vor 19 Tage
This is not slavery if they choose to go there. Stop blaming Italians when they didnt forced Indians to go to Italy.
markbr
markbr - Vor 21 Tag
God is just and will not forget all their hardwork. A feast is awaiting them in heaven
Dennis Abraham
Dennis Abraham - Vor 21 Tag
Do a documentary on Slavery in Saudi Arabia and the rest of the middle East, especially the plight of those who are forced to live in the inhuman conditions of a labour camp. I am writing this as a person who lived in Saudi Arabia
celtic knight
celtic knight - Vor 23 Tage
It has 666k views and 6 months old....
Jan lee Lee Jan
Jan lee Lee Jan - Vor 24 Tage
Illegal (foreign) workers/employment and opportunist employers around the world not just in Europe are still rampant....
Latif Ibrahim
Latif Ibrahim - Vor 26 Tage
If they think it's difficult there then they can move to the gulf countries where they will be sleeping in a single room with mates of ten to twelve... without their families around
Allan Sagahon
Allan Sagahon - Vor 27 Tage
3:17 why complain about such a thing?
Sunny Sahota
Sunny Sahota - Vor 29 Tage
All these illiterate Punjabis have one goal in life. That is, not to work hard in their home country, but to somehow go abroad at any cost and settle there. All pendus who are illiterates and incompetent think that in foreign countries, they will be living like kings. But here is the reality in this video of these morons. These pendus are keeping India a backward country...Never want to work hard and pay taxes to their government...a boy of my acquaintance, who hated studying in the school and hasn't even passed high school, and doesn't work at all. He keeps lying idle in his parents' house. He only has one intent, that is to go abroad. His parents are willing to invest and start him some business, but he isn't interested in that and bent upon going abroad. He is victimized by visa agents several times and even once refused twice visa by Embassy. They have money to squander on visa agents and embassy, but not to start any work. Years are going by and he is not willing to do anything back home. In most cases, poverty is not an issue among Punjabis, but their competition with their neighbors. Every villager is trying to go abroad by hook or crook. Bloody low IQ people...
ritesh kakkar
ritesh kakkar - Vor 29 Tage
sarawati mata in italy
Kumarajit M
Kumarajit M - Vor 29 Tage
Not bad as in our country they still better as my view
MusicOfEpirus
MusicOfEpirus - Vor Monat
How come no one cared about the Albanians?
We didn’t even have work. And when we did, we agreed to work for that much money. The choice was ours. We agreed to it. We did not complain.
Looks like these people are better connected to get DW to advocate for them. Those bad bad Italians.
Siddharth Tomar
Siddharth Tomar - Vor Monat
Sikhs and Hindus will mostly work and not demand welfare. They came here for a better living standard and I see most of them are enjoying the same. I guess local people don't want to work in farms.
Daniel Rojas
Daniel Rojas - Vor Monat
Always complaining but they don’t go back to their countries
Pietro Sammarco
Pietro Sammarco - Vor Monat
The same goes for Italian themselves, especially in the south. I am Italian and my dad is a farmer in the south and worked in the field 7 years. I never managed to make over 800 euros a month working 6 days a week, and sometime even 7. On and yes, in cash...
Buraidah
Buraidah - Vor Monat
emigrate
Roland Bustamante
Roland Bustamante - Vor Monat
I want to work there .
Blesto k mani
Blesto k mani - Vor Monat
Same as well all Europe
Axxess Mundi
Axxess Mundi - Vor Monat
Send them back
Ahmed Ismail
Ahmed Ismail - Vor Monat
They complain when none forced them onto it. Europe has the right to remain Europe, not to become India or the Middle East.
Mohan Gahalot
Mohan Gahalot - Vor Monat
Its easy to judge guys plz do not compare this to slavery they are free to move n go anywhere its just the choice
Shah Abdullah Shah12
Shah Abdullah Shah12 - Vor Monat
They are every where .ind
KENNY GILL
KENNY GILL - Vor Monat
Your only paid if you work ? Theres no place like home
Priyanka Upadhyay
Priyanka Upadhyay - Vor Monat
😂
Joash Manning
Joash Manning - Vor Monat
most of these labourers would be lucky if they earned €3.50 for a whole day of labour back in punjab. at €5.50 an hour... whether illegal or not, it's the most money an indian labourer will ever see in their life.
Lenlal HK
Lenlal HK - Vor Monat
And what about the expenditure,prices of food,medicines n rent..does that comes in rupees.. Fool
mac mor
mac mor - Vor Monat
No one hold them there, their choice , there is a lot of space in India for them.
doc72774
doc72774 - Vor Monat
Nobody wants to go back to India.... I wonder why?
Fortunato Wenceslao
Fortunato Wenceslao - Vor Monat
Sad. These people deserved more than what they are in right now. Life is not fair to all.
cyril john
cyril john - Vor Monat
Honestly speaking when he got out of his house with his wife and kid standing, before entering the car, watching his house I though it was some place in the Punjab or Bihar. Looks pretty similar with the shed and wires hanging around.
cyril john
cyril john - Vor Monat
This is a good life actually. Except for the trafficking. I'd love to go to Italy or Switzerland or France and work for a while to earn enough to own a small piece of land high up in the Alps secluded from the rest of the world. Just need to own a few cattle, hen, grow enough to trade it in the local market for some money to buy the things I don't get from my farm. No need for more than that. No need for a wife. A loyal buddy dog would be fine. The perfect setup for an introvert. Just live hand to mouth year to year.
sid
sid - Vor Monat
I don't understand why these same punjabi ppl abuse Indians from even poorer state like Bihar when Biharis go to work on their farm.what double standards.
Ranjit Tyagi
Ranjit Tyagi - Vor 14 Tage
+baljeet singh khosa What is this term "Saala Bhaiyya"?
baljeet singh khosa
baljeet singh khosa - Vor 17 Tage
Its not true.
Build it- Ride it
Build it- Ride it - Vor 29 Tage
Irony reins supreme in India.
Pawan Kumar
Pawan Kumar - Vor Monat
true
Legendary Eagle
Legendary Eagle - Vor Monat
You don't know what you are talking about, probably living a 1st world life assuming you know all the inner workings of a country on the other side of the globe.
The Complete Digital Lifestyle
It’s a very sad story. This shows how desperate Indian workers are to go to places like EU and Middle East to work as migrant workers and get paid low wages. It’s sad to see that the Indian Government does not bother to create more jobs back home and improve the lives of their fellow citizens. This is basically a suicide mission. People in India feel if they come to work in EU and Middle East as a migrant worker their lives will be better. This is just a big Lie!!
Fredrick Mboma
Fredrick Mboma - Vor Monat
6:04 what's Sylvester Stallone doing in police uniform?
Alessandro Forti
Alessandro Forti - Vor Monat
free hospital free school for the children and good pasta al dente in the best region of italy.
kenshin himura
kenshin himura - Vor Monat
if you are complaining about your salary,why are you still there,,,and yet you bring your family with you...go back to india,you said you can do business there,anytime you want to come to work your the boss..what are you waiting my friend...go back now
stevejabo
stevejabo - Vor Monat
I m ashamade for this, i m italian.Respect for punjub's people.
official Donald Trump
official Donald Trump - Vor Monat
What a joke
cosdache
cosdache - Vor Monat
Not only Indians .Italy is the country that treats immigrants the worst in Europe .Their competitive vegetables and fruit harvest in Southern Italy is supported by Romanians and Africans slaves .
anuj sharma
anuj sharma - Vor Monat
Don't worry one day we indian capture the whole world
Thubten
Thubten - Vor Monat
Sad to see they are eating maida roti. Punjab is famous for wheat and rice cultivation. So, my impression had been that all punjabis love to eat atta roti with lots of makkhan. In UP, even poor pple eat atta roti, not maida roti.
Michael Onyeka
Michael Onyeka - Vor Monat
This is another way of slavery
Edit name
Edit name - Vor Monat
Sikhs work hard wherever they are in the world
Caleb Dhewnarian
Caleb Dhewnarian - Vor Monat
Are these guys legal or illegal immigrants?
Salman Muzahir
Salman Muzahir - Vor Monat
And We are fighting neighbors , just look at these people.
Himself Lee
Himself Lee - Vor Monat
If people can work cheaply, they are obviously making more than they could otherwise or they would not be doing it. There is not a big profit margin in veggies. If they don't like it, they can go back.
ekundayowt
ekundayowt - Vor Monat
No pension no sick leave
Cameron Empey
Cameron Empey - Vor Monat
Makes you re think the cheap cost of food to a certain extent, even though It would be a lie if I said I don't mind the low cost it just shows you how messed up our systems are
Komal Singh
Komal Singh - Vor Monat
There can be no justification for exploitation. Pay people a decent wage. Even if people want to be in Italy. Why pay them peanuts.
Reasonably reasonable
Reasonably reasonable - Vor Monat
One should appreciate these jatt Punjabis sacrificing for their families in rural Punjab but what shocks most visitors to rural Punjab is how jatt Punjabis treat labour from poorer backgrounds themselves on the basis of caste colour and region etc
SuperHkang
SuperHkang - Vor Monat
Why dont Indians stay in India and make India GREAT ! like they do in the US.
SuperHkang
SuperHkang - Vor Monat
This is funny. sikhs in your country dont work hard but then they come out to a white man's country and work hard. Punjab is terrible place. clean up your own house first pls. India is a terrible country.
Sakshi Sharma
Sakshi Sharma - Vor Monat
why punjabis die to go abroad in other countries.
Asher Gavin Cole
Asher Gavin Cole - Vor Monat
Why don't they stop doing it. It wont happen again
Deen  Patel
Deen Patel - Vor Monat
This is good money for people with no education just multiply 5 euros for 10 that’s 50 euros per day and then by week and months and year ur a millionaire in India 😸
Krishoker TV
Krishoker TV - Vor Monat
t is not about Italy and non europeans. It is going on all over Europe
tintuu
tintuu - Vor Monat
I don't think its Italy but Punjab.
kedanpie4409
kedanpie4409 - Vor Monat
I’m 2 mins in and for a few euros an hour this man is able to relocate his whole family, have a stay at home wife and drives to work in his own car. I say life is pretty good...seeing that people working all their life and can’t afford such. Just saying.
H K
H K - Vor Monat
The Indians are not being exploited. The smugglers that they owe large debts to don't use guns to force the Indians to come to them and with them. The Indians are proactively seeking them out.
Susette Santiago
Susette Santiago - Vor Monat
Slavery has always been the Roman solution to everything...it's the Neanderthal factor...hit people over the head with a club and make them work for free
Wqm F
Wqm F - Vor Monat
Italy has a low working rate.... so, maybe they should be stricter towards Italians. Also, you can get cheap Polish people to do it too. Why Indians? lol
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker - Vor Monat
Just provide work visa to people from poor countries, change immigration laws to make it more strict, do not give citizenship to people just because they are born there....
Charlotte Vermeiren
Charlotte Vermeiren - Vor Monat
In india is geen oorlog
Venkatesh App
Venkatesh App - Vor Monat
For everyone grass is greener on another side
azog defiler
azog defiler - Vor Monat
Please dont call it exploitation it is a means of employment for them so that their families and kids have better future.
fedoracore321
fedoracore321 - Vor Monat
"Here your paid if you work" so is there another option?
kris wraa
kris wraa - Vor Monat
Love it
Jawad H
Jawad H - Vor 2 Monate
The truth is Asia is much richer then Europe, the growth is their and the opportunities are there.
Europe Topped long ago, all thats left is the struggle for the middle class.
Mr. Marco
Mr. Marco - Vor 2 Monate
Horrible
And they are crying about Gulf human rights really
Eugene Gillette
Eugene Gillette - Vor 2 Monate
Yes I agree with last person but give your lives to Jesus and we'll see each other in eternity Amen?
usha singh
usha singh - Vor 2 Monate
Sikhs are one of the bravest communities in the world. They have not only contributed to the growth of Indian economy but also the entire world. Hope they come out of this situation soon.
Omaima Al Najjar
Omaima Al Najjar - Vor 2 Monate
the officer in 7:22 looks very much like Sylvester Stallone!!!!!!!!!!
Miami Vice
Miami Vice - Vor 2 Monate
This is not the latest news.Saw this happening in Italy in 1995 and got worse from then also with East Europeans
Soni Singh
Soni Singh - Vor 2 Monate
Sikhs are hardworking and live any conditions so request to all countries president open door your countries for Sikhs especially agricultural
Gurpreet Singh Gurpreet
Gurpreet Singh Gurpreet - Vor 2 Monate
I am honest person and hard work hard working man I need working visa Italy please help me
Sajedul Haque
Sajedul Haque - Vor 2 Monate
European are big thief in the world
Gaz Gaz
Gaz Gaz - Vor 2 Monate
Why are you speaking hindi, when your mother tongue is punjabi..
Pitabas Bhoi
Pitabas Bhoi - Vor 2 Monate
Unless India control its population,it can't be developed.
K .H
K .H - Vor 9 Tage
Many States in India has very low fertility rate
Ramnik Kaur
Ramnik Kaur - Vor 10 Tage
We are controlling. Our southern states have achieved targets. Some states are behind,. what govt is making efforts. We have more young population in the marriageable age, so it will take time when it will stabilise.
Ravinder Sian
Ravinder Sian - Vor Monat
the fertility rate is close to replacement level now
K.J GREWAL
K.J GREWAL - Vor 2 Monate
The Punjabis who are working as farm labor currently in Italy are the future owners of Italian farms.
One of the most productive agriculture land in the world is located in the central valley of California and significant amount of that land is owned by Punjabi farmers who or their families originally started as farm labor and than moved on to becoming farm owners.
Same thing happened in the lower mainland of British Columbia in Canada and same thing is happening in Australia.
Eddy Parker
Eddy Parker - Vor 2 Monate
I don't know why?
But if I were him, I won't be leaving My Punjab for this piece of shit . Because where I used to live in Punjab's city is way more beautiful where he is Living now. Italy 😡🤬 however I understand his prospective he wants better for his children . I wish better life for him
Prince
Prince - Vor 2 Monate
Same in Portugal more bad situation.. Send your reporter here show you something more worst..
1mikon
1mikon - Vor 2 Monate
So he is a hardworking guy who tries to live a clean life..
royal dsouza
royal dsouza - Vor 2 Monate
India is rich country
Hamesha Indian
Hamesha Indian - Vor 2 Monate
some of the comments here are uninformed - which really is avoidable in this day of net access. every country imports labour - india inlcuded - from nepal and bangladesh in our case. it is upto that country to have a well run legal immigration system.

i agree illegal immigrants are breaking the laws but it is not a perfect world. As to taking jobs away - if the locals were willing to work as hard at the low remuneration paid no jobs would be lost.

India will reach replacement level fertility rate - 2.1 children per woman of reproductive age, by 2020 ! Yes the country has a big population and is struggling with lots of issues but so did Europe struggle with similar issues in the 17th and 18th centuries. And some of your problems were made better by forcible transfer of wealth from our countries to you.
M Tariq
M Tariq - Vor 2 Monate
I am not going to buy this 'Grammarly thing" any time soon. Too many ads, so annoying.
harprit kaur
harprit kaur - Vor 2 Monate
And italians are without a Job
John Mecole
John Mecole - Vor 2 Monate
That's true even in my region is even west cheap labor at cosenza, torano
Mohammed Hassan M
Mohammed Hassan M - Vor 3 Monate
Hi greeting I am from India
OUR WORLD
OUR WORLD - Vor 3 Monate
Am Indian please give one job me
Tina Phillip
Tina Phillip - Vor 3 Monate
Reminds me of Mexican and Caribbean farm workers in canada.minus the human trafficking
PARAS GAUR 15BEE1215
PARAS GAUR 15BEE1215 - Vor 3 Monate
Earn in India.
India is like mother ,and mother feed the child anyway.
SohaiL Rehman
SohaiL Rehman - Vor 3 Monate
*Atleast Give them minium wages*
Biju Karunakaran
Biju Karunakaran - Vor 3 Monate
Why no Indian media report this to Indian govt,or show this in India media.
Nada Denada
Nada Denada - Vor 3 Monate
Some racist shit heads don't understand that capitalism doesnt work without poor people.
vaanan navin
vaanan navin - Vor 3 Monate
I would work..if u pay same money.
R.B.R
R.B.R - Vor 3 Monate
The so-called “agents” make a bundle recruitment workers in India. These agents promised work all over the world (in “stable countries”) 10,000 dollars to work in Chile, 30,000 in Australia, 50,000 in the USA, etc. Etc.
jutubaeh
jutubaeh - Vor 3 Monate
6:50 29..? ^ ^
Nächstes Video